Printable & Template Review Rubric

Exemplary

Proficient

Not Proficient

N/A

Intent & Purpose

Exemplary

  • Purpose is clearly defined or implied
  • Organized structure and layout supports overarching purpose
  • All aspects needed to fulfill main purpose are included

Proficient

  • Purpose or intent is vague or unclear
  • Layout and structure aren’t ideal in achieving the overarching purpose; however, resource could be adjusted or revised
  • May not include necessary elements such as instructions or labels, but still usable with some creativity

Not Proficient

  • Purpose or intent cannot be understood
  • Layout and structure detract from original purpose
  • Many necessary elements missing; resource cannot be fully utilized

Images & Printing Quality

Exemplary

  • Graphics and layout support the purpose of the printable
  • Images are relevant to the content/purpose
  • Downloads and prints easily (if PDF or Word Doc) or includes a “print” option from a webpage
  • Prints cleanly and clearly (nothing is cut off or appears out of alignment after printing)

Proficient

  • Images may be slightly fuzzy or generic
  • Images slightly off-topic or unnecessary to the resource
  • Resource can still be printed out from a webpage, but doesn’t allow for a clean print view

Not Proficient

  • Images are indecipherable or very low quality
  • Resource is cluttered with irrelevant or crowded images that detract from the content/purpose
  • Resource cannot be easily downloaded or printed at all
  • Resource prints fuzzy or with low resolution

N/A

Language Conventions: Grammar & Punctuation

Exemplary

  • Virtually free of grammatical errors, as well as errors in punctuation, spelling, and/or capitalization

Proficient

  • Mostly free of grammatical errors as well as errors in punctuation, spelling, and/or capitalization

Not Proficient

  • Contains several grammatical errors and/or errors in punctuation, spelling, and/or capitalization

N/A

  • Resource has no text included

Customization

Exemplary

  • Allows for full customization if necessary (editing, adjusting, etc.)
  • Free from specific classroom language or details

Proficient

  • Allows for limited customization
  • May include a teacher’s name or specific classroom language (i.e. “The Mighty Mice Reading Group”)

Not Proficient

  • Does not allow for customization (editing, etc.)
  • Includes several terms clearly specific to one classroom

N/A

  • Resource does not need customization to be used to full potential

Classroom Application

Exemplary

  • Can easily be used or minimally adjusted for use in different classroom or administrative settings

Proficient

  • Is limited to use in only a few classroom or administrative settings

Not Proficient

  • Cannot be easily used or adjusted for use in different classroom or administrative settings