Plyler v. Doe: Can States Deny Public Benefits to Illegal Immigrants?

This Plyler v. Doe: Can States Deny Public Benefits to Illegal Immigrants? lesson plan also includes:

Illegal immigration is an ever-changing source of consistent controversy. A reading passage about the rights of undocumented workers and illegal immigrants—and the lack thereof—guides high schoolers into a mock trial activity. Three groups consisting of attorneys for the appellants, attorneys for the respondents, and Supreme Court Justices role play a trial in which they refer to a list of Constitutional questions to argue for or against applying the 14th Amendment's equal protection clause to school-age children of illegal immigrants.

12 Views 13 Downloads
CCSS: Adaptable
Instructional Ideas

  • Use the essential question in the resource title to guide a unit, shorter lesson, persuasive writing assignment, or formal debate
  • Conduct the mock trial in front of another social studies class, and discuss reactions afterward
Classroom Considerations

  • Use the attached resource to establish a protocol for discussing controversial topics
  • Consider providing additional articles or prompting groups to find outside information to challenge or corroborate their arguments
Pros

  • Provides revised Supreme Court procedure rules to facilitate instruction
  • Questions lend well to both discussion and writing prompts
  • Provides a resource to guide respectful discussion of controversial topics in the classroom
Cons

  • None