Lesson Planet
Search educational resources
  • Sign In Try It Free
  • AI Teacher Tools
    • Discover Resources Search reviewed educational resources by keyword, subject, grade, type, and more
    • Curriculum Manager (My Content) Manage saved and uploaded resources and folders To Access the Curriculum Manager Sign In or Join Now
    • Browse Resource Directory Browse educational resources by subject and topic
    • Curriculum Calendar Explore curriculum resources by date
    • Lesson Planning Articles Timely and inspiring teaching ideas that you can apply in your classroom
    • Our Story
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Testimonials
    • Contact Us
  • Pricing
  • School Access
    • Your school or district can sign up for Lesson Planet — with no cost to teachers
      Learn More
  • Sign In
  • Try It Free
Writing Is Elementary, My Dear Watson: Writing Paragraphs With Evidence And Reasoning Lesson PlanWriting Is Elementary, My Dear Watson: Writing Paragraphs With Evidence And Reasoning Lesson Plan
Publisher
K20 LEARN
Resource Details
Curator Rating
Educator Rating
Not yet Rated
Grade
9th
Subjects
English Language Arts
2 more...
Resource Type
Lesson Plans
Audience
For Teacher Use
Duration
2 days
Instructional Strategies
Collaborative Learning
4 more...
Technology
Presentation
Year
2021
Usage Permissions
Creative Commons
BY-SA: 4.0
cc
Lesson Plan

Writing Is Elementary, My Dear Watson: Writing Paragraphs With Evidence And Reasoning

Curated and Reviewed by Lesson Planet
This Writing Is Elementary, My Dear Watson: Writing Paragraphs With Evidence And Reasoning lesson plan also includes:
  • Writing Is Elementary, My Dear Watson (.pdf)
  • Lesson Slides (.pptx)
  • CER Outline (.pdf)
  • CER Outline (.docx)
  • CER Paragraph Guide (.pdf)
  • CER Paragraph Guide (.docx)
  • CER Peer Review Rubric (.pdf)
  • CER Peer Review Rubric (.docx)
  • Slylock Fox Brain Boggler (.pdf)
  • Slylock Fox Brain Boggler (.docx)
  • Tweet Up (.pdf)
  • Activity
  • Join to access all included materials

Did Smitty do it, or is he a victim? Sleuths apply their observation and reasoning skills to build a case for an argumentative paragraph. Class members closely observe a cartoon, make a claim, cite evidence from the image, and support their argument with logical reasoning. After a peer review of their drafts, your young detectives craft a Tweet about what they have learned about using evidence.

3 Views 4 Downloads
CCSS: Adaptable

Concepts

paragraphs, persuasion, persuasive arguments, persuasive language, persuasive techniques, evaluating claims, supporting evidence, peer editing, arguments, counterarguments, argumentative writing, the writing process

Instructional Ideas

  • Follow the lesson by having groups apply their sleuthing skills to solve "Two Minute Mysteries"

Classroom Considerations

  • Requires a projector for the PowerPoint and copies of three handouts for each pupil

Pros

  • Teacher notes offer additional support for instructors

Cons

  • None

Common Core

W.9-10.1.a W.9-10.1.b

View 41,140 other resources for 9th Grade English Language Arts

© 1999-2026 Learning Explorer, Inc.
Teacher Lesson Plans, Worksheets and Resources

Sign up for the Lesson Planet Monthly Newsletter

Open Educational Resources (OER)

  • Health
  • Language Arts
  • Languages
  • Math
  • Physical Education
  • Science
  • Social Studies
  • Special Education
  • Visual and Performing Arts
View All Lesson Plans

Discover Resources

  • Our Review Process
  • How it Works
  • How to Search
  • Create a Collection

Manage Curriculum

  • Edit a Collection
  • Assign to Students
  • Manage My Content
Contact Us Site Map Privacy Policy Terms of Use